Tuesday 30 April 2019

Reading Richard Rohr 2

Things Hidden: Scripture as Spirituality (London: SPCK, 2016; originally published in 2008 by St Anthony Messenger Press, Cincinnati, Ohio) is based on a set of talks given in 1998 on “The Great Themes of Scripture”.

The title (“things hidden”) is from Psalm 78:2, quoted in Matthew 13:35. The subtitle seems to relate to the other verse (partially) used to preface the book, 1 John 2:21.

“It is not because you do not know the truth that I write to you, but rather because you know it already.”

The introduction (“connecting the dots”) speaks of “thin-slicing” the (biblical) texts which refers to sifting, throwing off all that is irrelevant, focusing on “what really matters”. Once these prime ideas of Scripture are uncovered, others might re-cognise them as truth that had lodged in their own hearts but not yet risen to consciousness.

“My assumption throughout this book is that the biblical text also mirrors the nature of human consciousness itself. It includes within itself passages that develop the prime ideas and passages that fight and resist those very advances. You might even call it faith and unfaith ­– both are locked into the text.”

Faith is associated with “the Unfamiliar” – breakthroughs we may call “revelations” within the Bible, to be sifted from the familiar (small mind) terrain of unfaith.

“It might first feel scary, new or even exciting, but if you stay with the unfolding texts, you will have the courage to know them also as your own deepest hopes or intuitions. Such is the dance between outer authority and inner authority, the Great Tradition and inner experience.”

Rohr stresses the need for both, the external contribution of Sacred Scripture (“It takes all of the Bible to get beyond the punitiveness and pettiness that we project onto God and that we harbour within ourselves.”) and inner awareness (“We have far too long insisted on outer authority alone, without any teaching of prayer, inner journey and maturing consciousness.”)

My initial response: I sympathise with the observation that we have paid too little attention to “prayer, inner journey and maturing consciousness” and that this harms our reading of Scripture and ourselves. The idea of “sifting” between the wheat and chaff of Scripture, however, sounds very much like old-fashioned liberal Protestantism. I find the Christian tradition which hoped and even expected to glean goodies from every little crook and nanny of Sacred Scripture far more exciting.